Balkans Group has developed a monitoring instrument consisting of 8 dimensions: Rule of Law, Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, Democratisation, Economy, Sustainable Development, Education, Health, and Good Neighbourly Relations, to measure Kosovo’s progress. This structure is divided into thirteen (13) indicators and sixty-five (65) sub-indicators, which use means of assessment, means of verification, and sources of verification from a variety of local, regional, and international sources using both quantitative and qualitative data collection methods.

Hence, this report is much broader and more detailed than the EU’s country report. Balkans Group seeks to turn these indicators into a platform of information for citizens and policymakers regarding Kosovo’s progress in key sectors. READ MORE


Rule of Law
Human rights and fundamental freedoms
Democratisation
Economy
Sustainable Development
Education
Health
Good neighbourly relations

Rule of Law

Kosovo has made limited progress in rule of law in 2021.

Among the indicators, progress in the judiciary is the most evident, followed by the fight against corruption and the fight against organised crime.

In the judiciary, Kosovo’s institutions have achieved very good progress on the legal framework, good progress on accountability, some progress on efficiency and effectiveness, and limited progress on transparency, access to justice, administration of justice as well as independence and impartiality.

In the fight against corruption, some progress is noted in the confiscation of assets and legal framework. Limited progress is noted in public perception of corruption and prevention and no progress in measures against high-level corruption.

In the fight against organised crime, good progress was achieved on measures against trafficking in persons. Limited progress was made on measures against organised crime, terrorism, and violent extremism and the legal framework, whereas no progress was made on the fight against drugs/narcotics or money laundering.  

Kosovo’s institutions have achieved very good progress in the legal framework following the adoption of the Rule of Law Strategy and Action Plan. Progress in accountability and transparency is also evident as a result of better functioning of the Commission for the Evaluation of Judges’ Performance. Some improvements are identified in terms of efficiency and effectiveness, as the ratio of resolved cases reached 50%. Independence and impartiality have upgraded too. Public satisfaction with the work of courts has increased by 44%, whereas 36% with the work of the Prosecutor’s Office.

Access to justice has been limited, especially referring to marginalised groups (LGBTIQ+ and minority communities). The administration of justice has made minimal progress. The number of judges fell by 5% and the number of prosecutors by 4% in 2021. Yet, no progress has been recorded on the resolution of backlog cases, due to the growing number of inherited cases from the previous years.

The public perception of corruption has improved marginally with Kosovo’s Corruption Perception Index (CPI) moving from 36% in 2020, to 39% in 2021. Moreover, assets’ confiscation has experienced an increase of 53%. As for the prevention of corruption, cases dealt with by the Anti-Corruption Agency (ACA) have increased by 19%.

No progress was recorded in the measures against high-level corruption. In 2021, only 7 cases were investigated. This is due to the legal framework, specifically the incomplete Draft Criminal Procedure Code. Besides, the Law on the Agency for Prevention of Corruption (Law no 08/L-107) was not formally revised and there are no developments regarding the Law on Asset Declaration (Law No. 08/L-108).

Some progress is noted in the legal framework for the fight against organised crime with the approval of the draft Criminal Procedure Code (No. 08/L-032). While the New Strategy and Action Plan against Trafficking in Persons (TIP) and the Strategy and Action Plan for Countering Violent Extremism (CVE) are still in the drafting process, the measures against human trafficking have progressed with the filed indictments increasing by 93% in 2021. The same does not stand for measures against organised crime as the indictments increased by only 11%. The fight against drugs/narcotics is another area that had a decline, specifically the field indictments by the prosecution in 2021 decreased by 10%.

No progress is recorded with regard to the Law on Cyber Security and the Law on Prevention of Money Laundering and Financing of Terrorism.

Human rights and fundamental freedoms

No progress was reported in human rights and fundamental freedoms in 2021.

Limited progress is noted in civil and political rights and economic, social, and cultural rights. No progress was made on the legal framework. In civil and political rights, good progress is reported on gender equality, especially in regard to women’s representation at the central level, some progress is achieved on children’s rights as the implementation of the Law on Child Protection has started, whereas no progress is observed on freedom of expression, freedom of religion or the freedom of association.

Kosovo has made progress towards gender equality, where women dominate 8 out of 14 functional committees in parliament and 6 out of 18 government members are women. However, discrimination against ethnic minorities and marginalized groups, such as the LGBTIQ+ community, continues. There have been some advances in children’s rights, with a comprehensive legal framework in place, but implementation and decentralization of services remain a challenge. Progress in economic, social, and cultural rights has been insufficient, with barriers to equal access to employment and quality education. Property rights and freedom of expression also need improvement.

Democratisation

Progress in the area of democratisation was limited in 2021.

Limited progress is noted in media and civil society, elections, and public administration, whereas good progress is noted in political stability. There has been some progress in civil society, limited progress on freedom of media, and no progress on the legal framework. Some progress is reported on security and public order, constitutional and legal order, relations between the government and opposition, and the functioning of institutions. In elections, there is some progress on election administration and campaign environment, limited progress on women's representation, and no progress on the legal framework. In public administration, some progress is achieved in public finances, limited progress in the functioning of public administration, and no progress on service delivery, representation, or legal framework.

There has been progress in consultation with CSOs and transparency of public financing, with over 98% of policy and draft laws documents published in 2021. However, there has been no progress in media freedom compared to last year. The dismissal of all members of the RTK Board has been described as transparent. The number of threats and attacks against journalists and media increased by 21% in 2021. Some improvements have been made for whistle-blowers, but no progress has been reported in the legal framework. The proposed draft law to amend the Law on the Independent Media Commission is expected to pass in Parliament in 2022, which will also change the Law on Radio Television of Kosovo. Access to public information and the performance of oversight institutions deteriorated in 2021.

Kosovo has made progress in the functioning of the government. The Kurti II Government won 50.3% of the votes in 2020 and public satisfaction increased from 21.3% to 59.1% in 2021. However, there have been political disagreements with the opposition, leading to challenges in voting for international agreements that require two-thirds of the majority. There has been no progress in the functioning of independent institutions or in the implementation of the law, and political influence has affected the appointments and dismissals of senior officials. Laws related to public officials, conflict of interest, whistle-blowers, gender equality, procurement, discrimination, language use, and work have not been implemented in 2021.

Significant progress has been reported in the work of the Central Election Commission (CEC) in organizing and conducting the 2021 elections in Kosovo, which were generally calm and without serious incidents. Progress was also noted in the local and general election campaigns of 2021, except in areas with a Serbian majority. Some improvements were reported in the national elections, although the campaign was not in line with COVID-19 measures. Limited progress has been made in the representation of women, where only 14 women, or 8% of candidates for municipal mayor, exceeded the 30% quota. There has been no progress in reviewing the Law on General Elections, and no developments have been reported regarding changes to CEC regulations. The accuracy of the voter registry, which remains a challenging issue, has been somewhat improved. In the 2021 general elections, there were irregularities in vote counting, with a significant number of recounts delaying the publication and certification of results. In January 2021, the Committee on Budget, Labour and Transfers approved in principle the draft law on political party financing, but it was not passed.

In 2021, progress has been made in the transparency of public procurement as a result of two new modules in electronic procurement. E-Kosova has increased the number of electronic services offered to citizens, although these services were limited. The Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability Assessment for 2021 has shown good management of public finances in Kosovo, with transparency regarding the budget and its implementation. However, there has been no progress in the appointment and dismissal of high-level public officials and civil servants due to political influence. Citizen satisfaction with public services has decreased by 6.9%, and the drafting of a new law on salaries has been hindered by the lack of reliable data on salaries within and outside the civil service. The implementation of the Law on Public Officials is still in its early stages, and the new Law on the Organization and Functioning of the State Administration has not yet been fully implemented. The non-harmonization of sectorial laws with the General Administrative Procedure Law has caused legal insecurity for citizens and businesses, resulting in zero progress.

Economy

Kosovo has not made progress in the economy in 2021.

There is no progress in the economy as a whole, although limited progress is present in employment and safety at work. No progress is visible in the business environment, investments macroeconomic stability, human capital, or legal framework. Some of the challenges present in this dimension are trade imbalance, a considerable gap between newly registered and terminated firms, a large sector of the informal economy, insufficient foreign direct investments, and a high unemployment level.

In 2021, Kosovo has made progress in terms of GDP growth, with government revenues increasing by 8%, and foreign direct investment by 22%. However, the country still faces challenges in reducing the trade deficit, improving the business structure and formalizing the economy, which reaches up to 30%. Moreover, there has been no improvement in reducing the gap between new and closed businesses, and fatal accidents at work have only decreased by 18%. Kosovo has also not made progress in employment, job security, and migration. The implementation of the Sectorial Strategy 2018-2022 has been inadequate and the new Law on Labour and Law on Socio-Economic Council have not yet been approved.

Sustainable Development

Kosovo has not made progress in sustainable development in 2021, there is limited progress on the environment and no progress on energy.

There is limited progress on renewable energy and energy efficiency, and no progress on the energy supply or legal framework. In the environment, there is limited progress on air quality and waste management, and no progress on either the legal framework or water and land management.

Kosovo has made some efforts to improve energy efficiency, such as creating an Energy Efficiency Fund in 2019 and implementing environmental measures to improve the functioning of its thermal power plants. However, progress has been minimal in addressing commercial losses, ensuring energy security, and reducing greenhouse gas emissions, which in 2020 were estimated at up to 10,266 Gg (Giga grams) of CO2 (equivalent), or about 10.2 million tons of CO2 eq. A draft of a new Energy Strategy for the period 2022-2031 has been presented but not approved, and there has been no progress in implementing a gradual tariff adjustment plan. The integrated National Energy Climate Plan was not adopted and has no legal basis for its implementation without a Law on Climate Change.

Real-time air quality monitoring has shown good progress, but many cities in Kosovo still have poor air quality. The Action Plan for Air Quality is under review and progress has been made in some municipalities for integrated waste management plans. However, illegal dumpsites remains a problem. Kosovo heavily relies on coal and lacks effective measures to enforce the ban on coal for heating. The average annual water level trend in 2021 was negative compared to 2020. While almost 97% of the population had access to drinking water in both years, pollution from flooding and contamination of drinking water remains a problem that successive governments have done little to address. There has been no progress in the legislative framework and the Climate Change Strategy for 2019-2028 is still in its early stages. The Law on Waste needs to be further aligned with the Waste Framework Directive and the Forest Strategy and the Forestry Law were not adopted.

Education

Although there is a lack of data on the education sector for both 2021 and 2020, based on the available data, no progress is reported in this sector.

There is limited progress on access to education, however, no progress is observed on governance and quality of education, spending in education, and alignment with the labour market. The pandemic has certainly affected the quality of education but most obstacles in relation to the dimension have persisted over time. Increased spending on education, increased student enrolment rates for tertiary education, and alignment of curricula with labour market needs are some of the areas where progress has stalled.

In 2021, there was a 12% increase in spending on children with disabilities, but minimal progress was reported in infrastructure and investment spending, with only a 10.2% increase for laboratory equipment, renovations, and other materials. There has been no progress in research and education spending, which remains insufficient for students. Enrolment in higher education has increased by 26.4%, and there have been some advances in reducing the dropout rate for Roma, Ashkali, and Egyptian students and females. However, progress in graduation rates was insufficient, with only 6,193 students graduating in 2021. Kosovo’s membership in the European Quality Assurance in Higher Education (ENQA) was revoked in 2019 and has not been reinstated. Insufficient progress has also been reported in the recruitment and appointment of school directors based on meritocracy and in the professional training offered through the Support to Vocational Education and Training project in Kosovo, as schools face continuous challenges in aligning their curricula with market needs. No progress was reported in aligning the curriculum to improve the quality of education and vocational training.

Health

Kosovo has not made progress in health in 2021.

There is limited progress in managing Covid-19 in terms of vaccination. Also, limited progress is noted on access to quality healthcare and legal framework. No progress is reported on access to healthcare, and infrastructure. Poor health infrastructure and capacities, lack of a universal healthcare system, and insufficient implementation of a health information system are some core areas that need adjustment.

Kosovo has not made progress in improving its healthcare system, despite allocating 8.2% of the budget to healthcare and a 10% increase in overall healthcare spending compared to 2020. The country still lacks a universal healthcare scheme, and the 2013 law on healthcare provision remains in force. There has been no increase in the number of specialist doctors, and there were 6.4% fewer specialist doctors in 2021 than in 2020. In 2021, 71.7% of respondents believed that corruption had an impact on healthcare, although this is a slight improvement compared to 73% in 2020. 50% of the population has been partially vaccinated and 45% fully vaccinated against COVID-19. There has been a slight improvement in healthcare infrastructure and the adoption of a healthcare promotion and education strategy in 2021. Challenges in implementing the healthcare strategy include inadequate access to healthcare for one-fifth of the population, the cost of diagnostic services, non-reimbursement of medical expenses, and insufficient allocation of funds based on needs.

Good neighbourly relations

Kosovo has made limited progress in good neighbourly relations in 2021.

However, quantifying progress is more difficult compared to other dimensions. Among the indicators, there is some progress in terms of bilateral relations, whereas there is almost no progress in terms of regional cooperation and dialogue with Serbia.

There has been considerable progress in relations with Albania and North Macedonia. We have 13 agreements reached between Kosovo and Albania. There have also been several meetings between Kosovo and North Macedonia, and work is underway on an agreement to open the Border Crossing Point. Progress has also been made with Montenegro, with the signing of an agreement to eliminate vehicle insurance taxes for trips between the two countries. However, there has been no progress with Bosnia and Herzegovina. Kosovo has made some progress in implementing regional roaming agreements and has appointed a national coordinator to facilitate the creation of a regional market. However, there has been no significant progress towards membership in new organizations or initiatives. Dialogue between Kosovo and Serbia resumed in 2020, with minimal progress made in implementing agreements and reaching an agreement on license plates. However, progress in finding missing persons has been lacking.

 

Rule of Law
Human rights and fundamental freedoms
Democratisation
Economy
Sustainable Development
Education
Health
Good neighbourly relations



Qamil Hoxha street ob. no. 29
appartment no. 7,
Prishtina
10000, Kosovo


Opening Hours:

Mon – Fri: 09:00  – 17:00

 

Connect with us:

Exciting news! The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe voted in favour of the draft Opinion recommending Kosovo’s membership to the CoE!
Kosovo is now one step closer to joining the @coe and gaining access to its extensive mechanisms.

Load More